Resident Evil 2 Remake: GameDailydotReview

Capcom gives us 2019's first GOTY contender by bringing a new standard to remakes.

A little over three years ago, Capcom producer Yoshiaki Hirabayashi announced "we do it" -- they were remaking Resident Evil 2, first released on the original PlayStation 21 years ago this week. This announcement followed some teasing and genuine calls for feedback from the Resident Evil team on whether a remake was worth pursuing. It came a few months after the announcement at that year’s E3 of another remake, Final Fantasy VII, which might anecdotally be the most requested remake ever in games.

Now, three-and-a-bit years later since official confirmation of its development, REMake 2 is about to hit on PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and PC this coming Friday. And the consensus seems to be it’s the standard bearer for what remakes should be about: bringing a game to modern standards, but keeping the ethos of what made the original so beloved in the first place.

Shacknews gave the game a 9/10 (disclosure: Greenlit Content, also owns GameDaily.biz, counts Shacknews among its clients), said that we’re already looking at a GOTY contender with RE2. And we’re only in the early stages of late-January.

“Don't labor under the delusion that, if you played the original Resident Evil 2, that you should skip this one for some reason,” the review reads. “There’s no excuse of ‘I’ve already played the original, so I don’t need to grab this one.’ You couldn’t be more wrong if that’s your line of thinking.

“From top to bottom, this is already an early contender for Game of the Year 2019, and one of the greatest reasons ever to be a survival horror fan.”

The Daily Dot’s review, written by GameDaily.biz writer Joseph Knoop (scored at 4.5/5), asked a very poignant question in regards to games remakes:

“Here’s the thing with reviewing remakes of video games: Is it enough to simply list out the differences and similarities between each installment? I racked my brain trying to figure out an elegant way to compare and contrast, but quickly enough, an entirely different, far more modern game came to mind.”

Knoop added: “Resident Evil 2 doesn’t feel like its original incarnation. In parts, it doesn’t even feel like trendsetting Resident Evil 4, which brought an over-the-shoulder viewpoint and a heavier action focus to the series. Don’t even get me started on the series revitalization with the first-person Resident Evil 7.”

There were a lot of reviews that focused on the culture of remakes, and how they’re made, but one review decided to touch upon the zombies trend in pop culture over the past ten years.

“It’s not just video games that have been inundated with zombies over the past decade,” said Alan Wen in his 5/5 review for Fandom. “Whether it’s films, TV or theatre, seemingly not a month goes by without another age-old franchise undergoing reanimation in order to take over our time and wallets once again. When you put it like that, Resident Evil 2 Remake should feel like just another experience cashing in on our feverish desire to consume something familiar. Except, it turns out — this is no simple remake.”

Wen’s review added Resident Evil 2 has been able to bring back the old days of survival horror that not even Shinji Mikami, Resident Evil’s father turned creator of The Evil Within series at the Bethesda-owned Tango Gameworks, has been unable to produce in his time away from the RE series.

”It’s not just a loving restoration but a temple built on newly solid foundations, with emotional beats that genuinely resonate. It sets a new bar for what a video game remake can be, masterfully marrying nostalgia with modernity without quite being a slave to one or the other.”

There can be delicacies in remaking something so beloved. Vincent pointed out in her review for Shacknews that there are some elements that made the game so genuinely terrifying 20+ years ago aren’t in this iteration.

“Some classic enemies are nowhere to be found, however, such as spiders and crows, which may bug series purists,” she said, but noted that in their place were “a spread of interesting new enemies that'll have you shaking, though, so it's no huge loss. It's still something to keep in mind if you're looking for those big fuzzy arachnids and wondering how nasty they look in HD.”

Source: Capcom
Source: Capcom

Eurogamer’s Aoife Wilson gave it a recommended, noting that despite a change from the fixed cameras of the original game to an over the shoulder view similar to the one found in Resident Evil 4, 5 and 6, “it's a testament to the layout that locations still manage to be both claustrophobic and oppressive.” And it’s that claustrophobia that Wilson mentioned in her review that is touched upon in others.

“I spent most of my first playthrough carefully walking around (when I wasn’t being chased), checking corners and shining my torch into every nook and cranny, pausing at every zombie groan heard in the distance,” said Gary Bailey of God is a Geek in their 10/10 review. “I had to watch my ammo, choosing whether to take out a zombie or bypass them entirely. Inventory management is key in Resident Evil 2, as you strike that balance between carrying the right ammo and health items, while leaving yourself room to pick up new items and keys.

“When things get more heated, like when a boss is trying to put its giant claws through your face, the controls still feel tight and responsive. The only reason you’ll miss a shot is because you’re panicking at that rapidly approaching claw.”

Added Heather Alexandra in her review on Kotaku: “The remake instead adds tension by making its zombie hordes a resilience and menace unlike anything seen in the series before. Even when playing at the easiest setting, the player needs up to three shots to a zombie’s skull to dispatch of them. Once fallen, zombies can quickly rise again.

“You might use several bullets to clear a tight pathway only to find your foes have risen again by the time you come around for a return trip. The tougher enemies are initially interesting to fight, but I missed the tension that came from the larger crowds of enemies that swarmed players in the original.”

The one element that kept coming up a lot is Mr X/The Tyrant, the tormenter who chases you at numerous stages in the game, and is instrumental to the experience of Resident Evil 2. In his review for VG247, Kirk McKeand harkened the use of Mr X to the xenomorph in Creative Assembly’s masterpiece Alien Isolation, noting he’s basically free to do however he pleases. But the player can also use that to their advantage.

“You can also use his logic against him, drawing him to an area with gunfire before legging it to another wing of the station. Playing as Claire, you can get a silencer for your SMG that allows you to kneecap zombies in peace.”

But that being said, the horror that comes when first facing the humongous giant is telling, and comes across in quite a few reviews.

“The first few times you face him, panic takes over,” said McKeand. “The strange layout and tight corridors of the police station – a former museum – means that running without a purpose equals death. You have to constantly consult your map. Limited inventory capacity also forces you to make choices as to what key items to carry at any time, since they will be taking the space of ammo and healing items.

“Wherever you go, you have to go with purpose. You’re forced to pay attention.”

Added Knoop in his Daily Dot review: “I don’t know how they did it, but Mr. X might be the most terrifying persistent boss character in a video game since Alien: Isolation’s xenomorph stalked us in space. Intimidatingly well-done redesign aside, real applause must go to the binaural audio that permeates the whole of Resident Evil 2. When you’re facing down a small group of zombies or just crawling through a rain-soaked hallway, it’s grand stuff, but when this jerk is hunting you down, it’s positively pants-ruining.

Source: Capcom
Source: Capcom

“Mortal terror seems to triple when you’re not quite sure if he’s above or below you, but you do know he’s only one staircase from finding you. In one particular instance, I dipped into the RCPD S.T.A.R.S. office to elude Mr. X, and casually spent a solid five minutes too afraid to walk back out. Don’t mind me, I’m just making permanent friends with the shrubs and the late ’90s PCs in here. I wonder if they have Minesweeper…”

Said Wilson in her Eurogamer review: “He's still a horribly imposing and unpredictable presence, though there are moments it does feel unfair that when cornered by him in a dead-end corridor, there's no way to avoid him taking a swing at you other than unloading a couple of bullets into his head to momentarily stun him.”

And noted Matt Kim in his 4.5/5 review for USGamer: “I recall once how I was at a location I thought Mr. X couldn't access, only to look up and see him enter through another door in the area. Then he noticed me looking at him and turned around to come after me. I never felt safe in Resident Evil 2 and it was terrifying."

That’s not to say Mr X’s presence can’t get overbearing at times. In his 9/10 review for GameSpot, Alessandro Fillari said it can ruin the immersion of the game at times, even disrupting its pacing. “This is especially frustrating when you're simply trying to acquire an item or solve a puzzle in a room that the Tyrant and zombies frequent,” he said.

“What should be tense encounters can sometimes become annoying exercises in trying to lure it away, and in some cases it comes off like you're taking advantage of the Tyrant's rather limited AI to do just that. The Tyrant can overstay its welcome, but in most cases, its presence is a constant reminder of the looming threat throughout the game.”

But the hype for the game feels very real. In his 5/5 review for The Guardian, Keith Stuart said this was the best the series has ever been. “Let’s get this out of the way: Resident Evil 2 is the best game in Capcom’s long-running survival horror series and possibly the greatest example of the genre ever produced,” he said, later adding the game’s themes “will resonate just as much with younger audiences more familiar with Netflix than exploitation flicks.”

Resident Evil 2 is a remake that feels incredibly faithful to the original, paying homage through subtle music cues that recall classic pieces from the 1998 soundtrack, as well as telling the same story for a more modern audience.” added Bailey in his review for God is a Geek. “Not to sell it short however, as it’s far more than a simple remake: It constantly throws new things at you during the 12-15 hours of that first full playthrough. It feels like a whole new game that anyone can enjoy, as long as they don’t mind changing their underwear after each gameplay session. This is not just Resident Evil for a new generation.

“This is Resident Evil at its absolute best.”

Source: Capcom
Source: Capcom

Summed up by Kim at the end of his USG review: “The sense of fear and terror when playing Resident Evil 2 never leaves you and it’s unlike anything else I’ve encountered in a Resident Evil game previously. I’m just going to go ahead and call it: Resident Evil 2 is the best Resident Evil game in the franchise and represents a series and developer at its peak. Don’t be distracted by the pretty graphics and gore, Resident Evil 2 is straight-up dangerous.”

And further added in his review on VG247, McKeand added: “For my money, Resident Evil 2 Remake is right up there with Resident Evil 4 as the best game in the series. It’s the perfect blend of nostalgia and the new, marrying a classic game with contemporary game design, and a prime candidate for those Game of the Year lists. In January! Capcom clearly has no chill.”

And it’s on that final point by McKeand that’s worth touching on. Every January since 2017, Capcom has released GOTY contenders, starting with Resident Evil 7, whose shift to first-person ignited once again a series that was becoming stagnant. And last year’s Monster Hunter World exploded the series to new heights, stepping out as a niche series in the west to become a huge tentpole series for the publisher going forward worldwide beyond its mega success in Japan.

Now, Capcom has struck gold once again in January with the Resident Evil 2 remake. A remake that, according to a tweet by VG247’s Associate Editor, Alex Donaldson (who’s been playing the game), “is the gold standard for how to remake a classic game. It is f-----g stellar, and FF7 now has an even higher bar to clear.”

All in all, Resident Evil 2 has made quite the impression on game critics across the board (and across the ocean in Europe). The horror survival game is a cultural touchstone for many gamers in their adult years, as many of us have spent some time (whether it's in RE2, Code Veronica, the original Resident Evil, or the latest installation, Resident Evil 7) enmeshed in Raccoon City and its virulent inhabitants.

For more stories like this one delivered straight to your inbox, please subscribe to the GameDailyBiz Digest!

Johnny Cullen is a freelance writer and author from Derry, Northern Ireland who has written for Eurogamer, VG247, Official PlayStation Magazine UK, and so many more since July 2009. Come @ him about The Last of Us, Metal Gear Solid 3, Jonsi and Alex, or the Four Horsewomen of WWE on Twitter @JohnnyCullen.

GameDaily Connect Sponsors
Partners